Main conclusion

No directly tradable oil-to-Shell signal.

None of the tested configurations remained positive on the untouched holdout after the assumed transaction costs. On average, oil variables were no more predictive than Shell’s own recent price history.

Study overview

The study’s scope at a glance.

Source

WTI futures and SHEL one-minute candles

Study design

Chronological training, validation and holdout split

Target measure

Return over 5, 10, 15 and 30 minutes

Comparison

Shell only, oil only and combined

What did we want to find out?

Oil and energy stocks often move together. But does Shell follow oil in a way that allows completed one-minute data to predict the next 5 to 30 minutes?

The analysis used regular US trading hours and prevented returns from crossing trading-day boundaries.

How was it tested?

Chronological separation

Training ran until 4 December 2025, validation until 30 April 2026, and the completely untouched holdout began on 1 May 2026.

Four model types

Ridge models using oil only, Shell only or both were compared with gradient boosting and a constant baseline.

Conservative backtest

Only predictions above the validation threshold were traded. Overlapping positions were not allowed, and 10 basis points were deducted per trade.

Key results

The best predictive configuration was Ridge using Shell and oil over 30 minutes. The correlation was 0.0661, but the backtest remained negative after costs.

Model comparison for Shell and oil
Chart based on the published table below. Compare like-for-like measures only and account for uncertainty.
Horizon Model Directional accuracy Correlation Net
5 min Shell + oil boosting 48.72% 0.0064 −99.55%
10 min Shell + oil Ridge 48.13% −0.0079 −44.99%
15 min Shell + oil Ridge 48.36% 0.0023 −32.14%
30 min Shell + oil Ridge 51.31% 0.0661 −15.51%
30 min Oil only 48.45% −0.0049 −11.74%

Example predictions

The models produced an expected future return for each minute. The table summarises a separate top-20% signal rule for each horizon. The −70.06% result for the 5-minute rule is therefore not the same as −99.55% for Shell + oil boosting in the model comparison above: these are different configurations. The available export contains aggregated backtest results, not individual one-minute predictions.

Horizon Signal threshold Trades Gross After costs
5 min Top 20% 1,201 −0.49% −70.06%
10 min Top 20% 607 +0.94% −44.99%
15 min Top 20% 380 −0.77% −32.14%
30 min Top 20% 189 +2.06% −15.51%

What should you not infer?

  • SHEL is a US-listed ADR; WTI is not the same as Brent.
  • One-minute candles do not contain historical bid–ask spreads or precise execution prices.
  • With multiple models and horizons tested, the best result may partly reflect chance.

Research findings, not investment advice. Historical relationships do not guarantee future results.

Next study The overnight effect