Main conclusion

No convincing advantage from clusters or the model.

Clusters had a positive average abnormal return, but the interval included zero. The selected model’s accuracy remained below 50%, and selected signals lost money on average after costs.

Study overview

The study’s scope at a glance.

Source

SEC Form 4 open-market purchases

Study design

Event study with a reserved test period

Target measure

Sector-adjusted return over 5–60 days

Comparison

Individual purchases, clusters and a prediction model

What did we want to find out?

An insider purchase may signal confidence. Is a group of insiders buying within a short period more informative than a single purchase?

Only open-market purchases with transaction code P, a positive price and a positive number of shares were included.

How was it tested?

Cluster definition

At least two different insiders within seven calendar days, followed by a twenty-day waiting period to prevent overlap.

A fair starting point

Positions were opened no earlier than the opening of the first trading day after the filing date.

Reserved test period

Training ended before 2025. The model was selected during validation; the primary test began on 1 July 2025.

Key results

Over 60 days, clusters had higher average returns than individual purchases, but the proportion of positive outcomes remained below 50% and uncertainty was substantial.

Proportion of positive outcomes following individual insider purchases and clusters
Chart based on the published table below. Compare like-for-like measures only and account for uncertainty.
Horizon Type Events Mean abnormal return Positive
5 days Individual purchase 1,083 +0.18% 49.68%
5 days Cluster 227 +0.14% 50.22%
20 days Individual purchase 1,083 +0.54% 48.94%
20 days Cluster 227 +0.79% 47.14%
60 days Individual purchase 1,083 −0.53% 44.88%
60 days Cluster 227 +1.35% 48.02%

Example predictions

Examples from the reserved holdout. ‘Predicted’ is the expected sector-adjusted 20-day return; net returns include 10 basis points of costs.

Company Cluster? Predicted Actual Net signal return
GameStop No −2.93% −6.88% +6.78%
Hilton No −1.64% −1.04% +0.94%
Simon Property Yes −1.88% +0.36% −0.46%
Asana No +3.28% +0.77% +0.67%
Constellation Brands No +3.29% +0.77% +0.67%

What should you not infer?

  • The SEC bulk data does not include an exact acceptance timestamp.
  • Small and delisted companies are underrepresented.
  • Insider purchases can have many motivations and do not establish that the buyer had inside information.

Research findings, not investment advice. Historical relationships do not guarantee future results.

Next study Back to the independent replication